TL;DR
- Browserless: Managed browser access with unit-based usage, reconnect and replay options. Check plan concurrency and the cost of keeping sessions open.
- Browser Use: Cloud browser or hosted agent. Price browser time, network and model use separately and confirm your actual concurrency entitlement.
- Steel: Browser sessions with explicit time, proxy and CAPTCHA meters and a self-hosted route. Fifty concurrent sessions require more than the entry tier's ten.
- Bright Data: Browser API with network and unlocking in its product offer; price the workload by its applicable traffic contract, not browser hours alone.
- Apify: Run custom or selected marketplace Actors for a broader job and data pipeline. It is not automatically a drop-in replacement for every Browserbase session workflow.
- Migrate only after verifying sessions, state, task outcomes, cleanup, cost and credential ownership against the same acceptance cases.
The best Browserbase alternative depends on what you need to replace: a remote browser for existing Playwright code, a persistent login, a fleet able to absorb a burst, or the agent that decides what to click. Those are different purchases. A cheaper browser-hour price is not much help if reconnecting loses the session or the new provider cannot run enough concurrent jobs.
Start with Browserless for a familiar managed browser endpoint and session diagnostics; evaluate Browser Use when you want either a cloud browser or an agent layer. Steel offers managed sessions and an open-source path. Bright Data is more compelling for browser-based public-data collection where its network is part of the purchase. Apify can be a useful platform for owned browser jobs and Actors, but is a less direct replacement for an external, long-lived browser endpoint.
The recommendation changes when the requirement changes. For a deterministic account-research script, choose the runtime that preserves the required state and output at the right burst capacity. For an agent navigating unfamiliar pages, include model costs, action limits and approval boundaries in the same evaluation. None of the providers has been tested for this article; the proposed fixtures below are a buyer's test plan.
Which Browserbase capability are you replacing?
A browser automation framework controls a browser. A managed browser provider runs that browser, exposes a connection and offers operational features such as session logs or proxies. An agent may use a model to decide which action to take. You can replace one layer without replacing the other two.
Inventory your existing Browserbase workload before moving it: Playwright or Puppeteer version, connection method, session duration, contexts, browser version, regions and proxy configuration. Document where login state is stored, who owns it and whether parallel jobs can write to it. Then list browser-specific dependencies such as live debugging, recordings and the session API. A connection that works with a simple public page does not establish that an existing application can run unchanged.
Browserbase's pricing lists Developer at $20 monthly with 100 browser hours and 25 concurrent browsers, and Startup at $99 monthly with 500 hours and 100 concurrent browsers. Additional browser hours and proxy traffic have separate rates. At a required burst of 50, the cheaper plan's 25-concurrency limit matters even if the monthly hours would otherwise fit. Check current contract terms, timeouts and included features before treating a plan as the baseline.
Browserbase also lists separate Search and Fetch allowances on these plans. If the existing workflow uses those endpoints as well as browser sessions, inventory them before moving: a replacement browser endpoint does not automatically replace the included search or fetch capacity. Price the alternative services and their output contracts separately instead of attributing all migration cost to browser hours.
Our browser automation guide compares framework, agent and runtime choices. This article focuses on moving an existing runtime and preserving its operating contract.
How do the alternatives compare?
| Option | What you are buying | Best starting fit | Key migration check |
|---|---|---|---|
| Browserless | Managed remote browsers and related APIs | Existing browser scripts and operational visibility | Unit consumption, profile/reconnect semantics and concurrency |
| Browser Use | Cloud browser and optional hosted agent | Flexible navigation or own agent with a hosted browser | Initial concurrency entitlement, network and model charges |
| Steel | Managed sessions API with open-source path | Explicit usage meters and portability interest | Paid tier for burst capacity; profile and storage behaviour |
| Bright Data | Browser API with integrated data-access network | Public-site collection with network needs | Traffic bill, session lifecycle and compatible browser actions |
| Apify | Actor execution, datasets and optional browser workloads | A scheduled extraction job or owned custom code | Chosen Actor's endpoint, maintenance, state and concurrency |
Do not assume any provider carries Browserbase contexts, proxy settings, traces or secrets into a new account automatically. Select the deployment shape and test it with your own workload.
1. Browserless
Browserless is a natural comparison when the application already controls a browser with Playwright or Puppeteer. Its managed service offers browser connections, session management and plan-dependent logs and replays. For debugging, evaluate whether the retained replay exposes the information your operators actually need and whether access can be restricted to the right team.
The pricing unit combines multiple activities. Browserless documents one unit per 30 seconds of browser time, rounded up, with separate unit consumption for built-in proxy traffic and successful CAPTCHA solves. Its unit documentation measures how long the browser session remains open, including idle time; its reconnect guide explains how a session can remain alive between connections. A workflow that keeps sessions open while waiting, or loads heavy pages, can therefore cost more than active navigation time alone suggests. Confirm current reconnect metering for your configuration.
There is an unresolved wording difference: the pricing page says reconnects count as new connections with a fresh unit charge, while the unit guide describes charging the time the session remains open. Ask Browserless how reconnects and partial intervals appear on the invoice for your plan, and measure them in a small controlled trial before relying on a cost estimate.
The displayed annual-billing Starter plan is $140 per month equivalent with 180,000 units and 40 concurrent browsers; Scale is $350 per month equivalent with 500,000 units and 100 concurrent browsers. Confirm monthly billing and the precise concurrency entitlement at checkout. The page also displays additional concurrency indicators; verify whether those are included or purchased before deciding which plan supports 50 simultaneous sessions.
Best fit: managed browser work whose team values browser connection compatibility and retained diagnostics. Non-fit: a buyer expecting its included units to be unlimited browser time plus free proxy traffic, or assuming idle sessions stop consuming units.
2. Browser Use
Browser Use separates cloud browser infrastructure from its hosted agent and open-source agent tooling. That makes it useful for two different migrations: connect your own automation to a cloud browser, or delegate navigation decisions to a hosted agent. The second changes the application contract, because an agent deciding what to do is not identical to a script executing fixed steps.
The pricing page lists browser time at $0.06 per hour, home-IP traffic at $5 per GB and direct or customer-proxy traffic at $0.20 per GB; any external proxy supplier remains a separate purchase. Agent model use is additional. The page shows concurrency increasing with cumulative paid usage, starting at ten simultaneous browsers and listing 50 after $100 total paid. Confirm the current entitlement, top-up terms, billing rounding and availability for your account before planning the burst.
Best fit: a team that wants a choice between bringing its own logic and using an agent layer. Non-fit: expecting a very low browser-hour rate to include unlimited traffic, all model calls or immediate access to every listed concurrency level.
3. Steel
Steel provides a managed sessions API and an open-source browser project for teams that want to investigate operating their own infrastructure. That can be valuable for deployment control, but the open-source route requires staff to own hosting, updates, monitoring and incident response. Check the licence and feature differences for the exact deployment; “open source” does not mean the managed service is free.
Steel's public Launch tier lists ten concurrent browser sessions, sessions up to 15 minutes, $0.10 per browser hour and $10 per GB of proxy bandwidth, with a one-time usage credit. Scale lists $250 per month, $100 in monthly usage credits, 100 concurrent sessions and usage at $0.08 per browser hour and $6 per GB. CAPTCHA solves and other tools have separate meters. Confirm whether your use consumes credits and how session durations round. For a 50-session burst, Launch's ten-session capacity is a constraint regardless of its lower base fee.
Best fit: a team wanting defined session and network meters with a path to investigate self-hosting. Non-fit: a buyer comparing Scale's $0.08 rate without its monthly fee or treating its usage credit as cash that carries forward indefinitely.
4. Bright Data
Bright Data's Browser API combines browser infrastructure with its network and unlocking features. Its public page lists support for Puppeteer, Playwright and Selenium, and describes a traffic-based pricing model. That makes it an alternative when the core job is acquiring and interacting with public web pages and the network component is important to the buyer.
The published pay-as-you-go Browser API rate is $8 per GB, with built-in proxies and unlocking; the page also lists a free tier and a separate Scale subscription. The navigation's lower starting price is not the pay-as-you-go rate. Run the same allowed public-site navigation and verify the observable result, not just whether a page opened. Confirm how session state is maintained, what traffic counts towards billing, how failed requests are charged and what your regional configuration costs before purchase.
Best fit: network-intensive collection where browser and proxy infrastructure are being purchased together. Non-fit: assuming that its separate Scraper API price per delivered record is the price for an arbitrary interactive browser session.
5. Apify
Apify packages work as Actors, which can run code and return stored data. It is a useful alternative architecture when the existing Browserbase application really consists of a scheduled browser job: put the navigation and extraction in an Actor, then call the Actor and retrieve its dataset. A team can also investigate individual marketplace Actors or build its own.
A community-maintained Browser Pool Actor describes a standby browser endpoint. At our review, its listing reported no monthly active users and a last modification two years earlier. That is a signal to investigate maintenance, not proof that the Actor cannot work. The listing is not a guarantee of a first-party managed Browserbase-equivalent service or a production support commitment. Evaluate the maintainer, implementation, connection method, security and current activity; a custom Actor may be the better supported route for a critical workflow.
Apify's pricing distinguishes platform resource usage from an Actor's event or usage pricing. Starter is listed at $19 monthly with prepaid platform usage; compute, proxy, storage and a selected Actor's own fees may matter. Concurrent Actor runs and concurrent browsers inside a run are different limits. Ask the supplier for the exact deployment shape and applicable capacity before treating either number as the other.
The published Starter plan lists 32 concurrent Actor runs, while Scale lists 128. If your architecture requires one Actor run for each of the 50 jobs in the burst, Starter's stated run limit would not accommodate all 50 simultaneously without an add-on or a different arrangement. If an Actor manages multiple browser tasks internally, its browser concurrency and resource needs are a separate question. Do not apply the 32-run limit as a universal limit of 32 browsers.
Best fit: a team that benefits from owning a complete extraction job, schedule and dataset. Non-fit: expecting every marketplace Actor to expose an identical persistent browser API or to be maintained by Apify itself.
How should you test migration and session recovery?
Use the same synthetic acceptance fixture for each contender. It is a proposed evaluation, not a test we performed. Host a small public test site you control with a company page, a JavaScript-loaded careers list and a filter; use a separate authorised test login if persistent state is required. Supply the domain and output schema to every implementation.
- Open the company page, follow the careers link and select a specified location. Output the company domain, selected filter, matching job title, source URL and retrieval time.
- Verify that a wrong company domain is rejected, an empty result stays empty and an inaccessible page becomes an error rather than a fabricated answer.
- Save progress outside the browser after the company page. Interrupt the connection during the careers step and attempt the documented reconnect. Check whether the same page and authorised session remain, then resume without repeating the completed output.
- End the browser through the provider's documented lifecycle, start a new session using the intended persistent context and confirm the authorised test login behaves as expected. A connection drop, session termination and creation of a new browser are three different events.
- Run two isolated test users concurrently. A credential, cookie or output from one must not appear in the other. If several workers share a profile, test the provider's documented write and conflict semantics before allowing concurrent updates.
- Simulate an unavailable page, an expired login, timeout and failed browser close. Confirm retry limits, redacted logs, alerts and eventual cleanup. Record browser time, traffic, reconnects, model tokens and queue time separately.
For the burst, submit 50 jobs simultaneously and measure how many start, queue, fail or time out. Define acceptable completion time in advance. A provider's advertised concurrency is an entitlement to check, not evidence that 50 jobs complete within your deadline. Use only sites and accounts you are authorised to access and respect applicable terms.
A useful output contract includes job_id, source_url, observed_at, result, error, browser_session_id and evidence_reference. Do not store credentials in the result or expose login pages in broadly shared replays. Reconcile completed job IDs after a timeout before replaying work; a client timeout does not prove the browser failed to finish.
What might 10,000 sessions cost?
Assume 10,000 successful five-minute sessions plus 100 one-minute retries: 50,100 browser minutes, or 835 hours. The workload also uses 20 GB of provider proxy traffic, has a peak of 50 simultaneous sessions and incurs an assumed $20 of external model charges. It is an illustrative input, not a measured result or a promise of equivalent performance. Prices and allowances below should be reconfirmed at purchase; they exclude tax, storage beyond plan allowances, engineering and any extra CAPTCHA or provider-specific charges.
| Route | Calculation on the stated assumptions | Illustrative monthly subtotal |
|---|---|---|
| Browserbase Startup | $99 + (835 − 500 included hours) × $0.10 + (20 − 5 included GB) × $10 + $20 model | $302.50 |
| Browser Use | 835 × $0.06 + 20 × $5 home-IP traffic + $20 external model | $170.10, subject to 50-session eligibility |
| Steel Scale | $250 + max(0, 835 × $0.08 + 20 × $6 − $100 monthly credit) + $20 model | $356.80 |
| Browserless Scale, annual billing equivalent | $350 + $20 model; 100,200 browser-time units and 120,000 residential proxy units fit 500,000 included | $370, before other units |
| Bright Data Browser API, gross pay-as-you-go | 20 GB × $8 + $20 model | $180, before any free allowance or additional charges |
| Apify Actor | Price its compute, proxy, storage and any Actor events, plus $20 model | Deployment-dependent |
For Browserless, the calculation assumes each five-minute session consumes ten 30-second units and each one-minute retry two: 100,000 + 200 = 100,200 time units. Assuming 20 GB equals 20,000 MB for this illustration, residential traffic adds 120,000 units, or 220,200 units before CAPTCHA and any additional open-session time. Confirm the provider's bandwidth definition and actual metering. Its Scale row is an annual commitment expressed per month, whereas the other listed bases do not make that assumption.
Browser Use's pricing FAQ says browser time is billed by the minute with a one-minute minimum. The five-minute sessions and one-minute retries in this particular scenario are already whole minutes, so the 835-hour arithmetic needs no additional minimum-time adjustment under that rule. A workload with many shorter sessions would need a separate calculation using the actual billing method and any other applicable charges.
The 50-session requirement changes the answer. Browserbase Developer's 25-concurrency baseline and Steel Launch's ten sessions cannot serve the assumed burst simultaneously. Browser Use's self-serve concurrency unlock depends on total paid; a new account may need a different arrangement. Browserless displays Starter at 40 with an additional concurrency indicator; check whether that indicator is included, purchasable or conditional before ruling Starter in or out. The Scale calculation is a qualifying conservative comparison, not a claim that a lower configured tier cannot qualify.
A comparable operational budget also includes the costs of failure. If 200 jobs require five minutes of human investigation, that is 16 hours and 40 minutes. At an assumed $60 per hour, add $1,000. A provider that saves a few dollars in browser runtime but generates more unresolved sessions may cost more per usable research result. Conversely, paying for recordings nobody uses will not improve an otherwise stable workflow. Track completed, source-backed jobs and review time as well as infrastructure consumption.
How do you choose and migrate?
Choose Browserless for a managed connection and debugging comparison; compare its unit and concurrency terms on your actual session pattern. Choose Browser Use for its separate browser and agent routes when your entitlement fits the burst. Choose Steel if a managed sessions API and an open-source deployment option are important, and the Scale tier's fixed cost buys needed capacity. Choose Bright Data when public-data access and network coverage are the main workload. Choose Apify when moving the whole job into an operated Actor and dataset is useful.
Before cutover, store your navigation code independently of the provider, export non-secret job configuration and map each Browserbase-specific API call to its replacement. Confirm retention and deletion for logs, recordings, cookies and downloads. Set a cost and queue alert, then shift a small read-only cohort with the old service available for rollback. Compare output, errors and human review, not just HTTP success. Keep login and other site credentials in your secret manager; transfer only what is authorised and needed.
If the browser is just fetching a known public page, a web extraction API may be a simpler purchase. For the surrounding jobs and ownership, use the GTM engineering playbook. The browser is one component of an evidence-backed workflow, not the entire account-research system.
FAQ
Can I change the Browserbase endpoint and keep the same code?
Sometimes a familiar browser protocol reduces the work, but it does not prove feature parity. Context creation, authentication, proxies, session termination and debugging APIs can differ. Run the actual navigation and recovery cases before promising a no-code migration.
Does persistent state guarantee a completed task?
No. Cookies or local storage may survive while the job's output or its last successful step is lost. Persist progress and evidence outside the browser, and use a job ID to determine what needs retrying.
Is a cheaper browser-hour rate always the cheapest choice?
No. Bandwidth, minimum session increments, concurrent capacity, proxy configuration, model usage and labour can exceed the browser-time line. Compare the same workload and define a usable result before deciding.
Should every task use an AI agent?
No. A repeatable navigation path can often be specified in code. Add an agent when choosing actions on unfamiliar pages provides enough value to justify its reasoning cost and variability. Give it an explicit action and time budget.





